“Small Government,” my lady parts!

Happy Hour Debate

For a political party to stake its flag in “No Big Government” territory and then countenance government interference between a woman and her physician is just about as far into the Hamlet of Hypocrisy as one can inhabit.  And, there they went again, as expected, into the manufactured poutrage over the debunked Planned Parenthood video.  First, the Happy Hour:

“This is absolutely disgusting, and revolts the conscience of the nation,” Louisiana Gov. Bobby Jindal said of secretly-recorded videos of Planned Parenthood executives discussing fetal tissue research. “We just, earlier this week, kicked them out of Medicaid in Louisiana as well, canceled their provider contract,” Jindal said. Then, seemingly undermining his case that the undercover videos related to his decision, Jindal added, “They don’t provide any abortions in Louisiana.” [MSNBC]

Yes, what’s “absolutely disgusting” and “revolts the conscience of the nation,” is that anyone would fall for the manufactured propaganda piece in the first place.  Additionally, to blunder into the questions associated with fetal tissue research AND note that PPA doesn’t provide abortion services in Louisiana is about as silly as it gets.  However, Jindal’s found a way to cut Medicaid in his state by canceling their provider contract – which means that the 80% of PPA clients who avail themselves of PPA medical services won’t be getting any help avoiding unwanted pregnancies.  Nor will they be getting STD/HIV/AIDS screening, or cervical cancer screenings, or breast cancer screenings. [PPA]

Former NY Governor George Pataki should have known better:

“You know, Hillary Clinton’s always saying how Republicans don’t follow science? Well, they’re the ones not listening to the scientists today, because doctors say that at 20 weeks that is a viable life inside the womb,” Pataki said. “And at that point, it’s a life that we have the right to protect, and I think we should protect.” [MSNBC]

Not so fast!   The science is a bit different than what Gov. Pataki is asserting. The New York Times reported the latest research results:

The study, of thousands of premature births, found that a tiny minority of babies born at 22 weeks who were medically treated survived with few health problems, although the vast majority died or suffered serious health issues. Leading medical groups had already been discussing whether to lower the consensus on the age of viability, now cited by most medical experts as 24 weeks.” 

Get the “tiny minority” and “vast majority” observations?  And, the part about “leading medical groups” citing 24 weeks as a minimum.  The American Academy of Pediatrics adds, “Determining the survival prognosis for the infant of a pregnancy with threatened preterm delivery between 22 and 25 completed weeks of gestation remains problematic.”    There are at least 8 pre-natal screening tests [ACOG]  There’s a reason for the problems, an ultra-sound ‘fetal anatomy survey’ is a test used at 17 to 20 weeks.  If a woman opts for blood screening tests the ‘sequential integrated screen’ is done at 10-13 weeks, and the second blood test is performed between 15 and 20 weeks.  The ‘serum integrated screen” is performed at 10 to 13 weeks, and the second between 15 and 20 weeks.  [Healthline] Noticing a pattern here? It should be noted that the “anomaly ultrasound” is usually completed around 18-20 weeks. [CDC] Most of the second tests are performed at or around 20 weeks, the results may be in the works when the clock runs out if the forced-birth folks have their way. 

No one is contending that a woman must have an abortion if a fatal defect is discovered in the second trimester.  Perhaps it would help the politicians to remind them that 0-13 weeks is considered the first trimester, 14-26 weeks the second, and 27 – 40 the third.  What rational people are asking is that the woman and her family be the ones who decide if between 20 and 26 weeks  an abortion is necessary to prevent the woman from having to carry a fetus with a fatal birth defect to term.  Governor Pataki should review some of the medical information easily available online before buying into the Radical Right Anti-Choice propaganda.

And then there was Senator Lindsay Graham.

“I don’t think it’s a war on women for all of us as Americans to stand up and stop harvesting organs from little babies,” he said, referring to a legal process by which women can donate the fetal remains after abortion for the purpose of medical research.” [MSNBC]

No, Senator, this isn’t Harvest Time.  We are talking about fetal tissue, donated by women voluntarily for medical research. Tissue which helped find a vaccine for polio, and which is assisting researchers find cures and treatments for such conditions as  Parkinson’s Disease, Lou Gehrig’s Disease (ALS),  and macular degeneration. [See previously DB]

Senator Graham is a lucky man – he was born July 9, 1955,  after the (inactivated) injected polio vaccine was developed by Dr. Jonas Salk (1953) and after about 2 million children participated in the 1954 field trials, and after the April 12, 1955 Ann Arbor, MI, press conference announcing the success of those trials.  Between 1955 and 1957 the incidence of polio declined in the United States by 85% to 90%. [AmHistSci]  There would be no more reports, as there were in the 1940’s and early 1950’s of some 35,000 children and adults contracting the dread disease every year. [CDC] And this, because some courageous and compassionate women donated fetal tissue for medical research.

And then there was former Senator Rick Santorum. Who sidestepped the question and went straight for promoting a Partial Birth Abortion Ban law, heedless of the fact that this is NOT a birth, that survival rates for infants actually born weighing 500 grams or less is 14%, [Slate] and that “partial birth” isn’t a medical term, it’s a political term coined by anti-abortion activists. [NPR]

Once the Happy Hour was complete, the main show included Wisconsin Republican Governor Scott Walker proudly announcing that he’d closed down Planned Parenthood in his state four years ago.   Correction: He still has 22 PPA centers in the state, but five did have to close after the state withdrew $1 million in funding from any facility that provided abortion services. [CBS]

The true danger to himself and others is former Governor Mike Huckabee, who wants to apply the 5th and 14th Amendment guarantees to the unborn. Somehow, Mr. Huckabee has invented his own new pseudo-medical term: “DNA schedule.” There is NO DNA schedule. Much less is there a unique DNA schedule for every human being at conception. [CBS] But then, we have to remember that this is the same man who lashes out at any hint of equal protection (under the 5th and 14th amendments) for members of the LBGT community, but finds the Duggar Quiverfull folks perfectly acceptable.

Moving right along:

“Sen. Marco Rubio was on the defensive after debate moderator Megyn Kelly suggested that the Florida Republican would “favor a “rape and incest exception” to abortion bans.

“I have never said that,” Rubio objected. “And I have never advocated that. What I have advocated is that we pass law in this country that says all human life at every stage of its development is worthy of protection.” [CBS]

Really?  Because CBS news did a bit of fact checking:

“But he appears to be wrong about never having advocated the exception. In 2013, Rubio cosponsored a Senate bill with wide-ranging Republican support called the Pain-Capable Unborn Child Act, which would have banned abortions after 20 weeks, and that bill had exceptions for rape, incest, and in cases when the mother’s life was threatened.”

Who’s arguing? Yes, all human life is worthy of protection, but most sentient beings include the mother in that equation.  So, Senator Rubio, are you now contending that the health and well being of the mother is of no consequence in the formulation of laws concerning abortions?  Are you perfectly willing to orphan the remaining children in the family in order to save a fetus?

And The Donald? Who knows. He jabbered for 10 minutes and 30 seconds. [HuffPo]

None of this should be surprising, other than offering “Repeal and Replace” rhetoric tossing some 19 million working men and women out of their health insurance coverage, and allowing the Banksters to avoid all those pesky regulations which might help ease if not prevent the next financial calamity (Sarbanes-Oxley, Dodd-Frank), and tossing more funding into the next glorious war – they really don’t have anything on offer for climate change and voting rights…. So we’re back to the same old Trickle Down Economic Hoax, and “wedgie issues.”

Now we have 65 weeks before the 2016 general election…. Not quite long enough to cover the 91 week gestational period of an African Elephant…

Comments Off on “Small Government,” my lady parts!

Filed under abortion, Health Care, health insurance, Lindsey Graham, Medicaid

Comments are closed.