Oh mercy me! Merciful mercies…there are 5000 migrants “storming” our southern border, waileth the Trumpian fearmongers, intent as they are on creating a curtain of dread veiling the eyes of those who are susceptible to such manipulation. Let’s take what’s probably an inflated number (5,000) of people seeking to apply for asylum along our southern border and compare that to some other examples of people “storming” in lines we see every day.
For example. The Clark County Department of Aviation compiles statistics on the number of people who “storm” McCarran International Airport. (pdf) Wow, thus far in 2018 we’ve been “stormed” by 25,013,841 people! But wait, we like these people. They come, some spend money at the airport, some get off the planes in Terminal 1 and go spend more money in our special Nevada play zones; playing with cards, and machines, and things with bells and whistles designed to help separate our tourists from their dollars. Now, get out the old plastic brains and punch in 5,000 and divide that by 25,013,841. Hint: You are going to get a small number with an exponent “e-4” on the tail end of it. We can play with these numbers a bit more.
Try this. Compare the 5,000 “storming” the southern border with the McCarran traffic for one month. Let’s take a happy month for us — July — with many happy people who land in Nevada’s sunny climes to part with their paychecks; 2,991,599 of them in the month of July. There are 31 days in July, so divide the number above by 31. No exponent this time. There’s an average of 96,503 passengers using terminal 1 each day in July. Now, divide 5,000 by 96,503 and you’ll get 0.0518, turn that into a percentage and it’s 5.2%. In other words the “storm” at the US southern border is a measly 5.2% of the number of passengers using McCarran International Airport Terminal 1 on a SINGLE DAY in the month of July.
We can play with some other numbers from the northern part of the state, for example, RTC ridership in Washoe County. The RTC published a report of YOY comparisons for April 2016 (pdf) reporting 105.082 rides on the RAPID system, coming in at about 43.8 rides per service hour. Handy calculator time again please. Our word problem solution for this one is that 5,000 “stormers” are about 4.8% of the rides on the Washoe RTC RAPID system. Not so much of a storm huh?
But wait, cry the fearmongers, these stormers will clog up our social services and get welfare… uh, not so much, non-citizens in Nevada aren’t eligible for social service benefits. But but but — they’ll pack our schools! There are 492,496 youngsters enrolled in Nevada public schools (exc downld) and again our calculator hops into action. If every single one of the 5,000 Stormers from the “Great? Caravan” were a school aged youngster and they all enrolled in a Nevada public school they’d constitute a — wait for it — a 1.01% increase in public school population. Hardly the stuff of alarmist proportions. Realistically, they aren’t all school aged, they aren’t all coming here, and they aren’t anything remotely like a “storm” of invaders upon our southern flank. Please take two deep breaths and call a friend for consolation prior to any more anxiety attacks based on “swamping” our schools blathering.
So, why all the televised emphasis on the “caravan?” It’s good “optics” for the racists. Get a nice tight crowd shot of “illegals storming” the border and the fear factor kicks in — much more so than if we emphasize the FACT that most visa over-stays are people who fly in.
“DHS has determined that there were 52,656,022 in-scope nonimmigrant admissions to the United States through air or sea POEs with expected departures occurring in FY 2017; the in-scope admissions represent the vast majority of all air and sea nonimmigrant admissions. Of this number, DHS calculated a total overstay rate of 1.33 percent, or 701,900 overstay events.”
Excuse me, but I’m having a problem here envisioning a “storm” of unlawful entries into this country when we have most visa overstays dribbling in through POEs by air and sea, and there’s a 1.33% overstay rate. What I’m not having a problem seeing is that people like the current POTUS, and his sidekick the virulently racist Stephen Miller, are driving a PR campaign to convince people that Brown is Bad, and that “hordes” of “those (read ‘brown’) people” are “storming” our southern border. I’m not buying it, and frankly speaking I don’t think anyone else should be buying into their malarkey either.